Eve the Pie'd Piper specializes in hand-crafted pies, and there's a wide variety from which to choose. Eve the Pie'd Piper also offers a selection of quiches & pot pies, cheesecakes, and specialty baked goods. Baking is my passion, so give me a try, if you're hankering for something you remember from your own family, or just want to try something new. Any of my products may be customized to fit your dietary needs (such as low sugar, alternate sugar, or gluten free), or ingredient preferences.
Weekly Specials
Provide an email to receive the Saturday eBlast, & be 'in the know' for upcoming events.

Delivery is Fri., 7/19.  Pls order by 8 AM, Wed., 7/17.
FYI:  Next posting is Sat., 8/3 for Fri., 8/9 delivery.

Sour Cherry shipment just came in!

- 9" Sour Cherry $29 in pic ->
- 9" Mumblecherry $29
- 9" Sour Cherry Cheesecake on a Cocoa Graham crust $28*
*It freezes great!!

First-come, first served on extra GA peaches:
 I have enough for one more 9" pie. 

- 9" Peach $28
- 9" Peachy Blue $28 


ALL pies/quiches/pot pies/cheesecakes are available in the 5" size (min. order is 2, unless with another item), or as a 4-pack of the individual 3 1/2" size.  See 'Ordering' tab.

I'm certified by the OH Dept. of Agriculture/Division of Food Safety.  I continue to use required, sanitary procedures in preparation, baking, and in my delivery to you in person, or a spot you designate.

To browse the selections, tap 'Product' box above for category window at left. Scroll to choose which, then tap 'Done.'
Image Not Available

Pie'd Piper Essentials

Crusts: Most pies are made with my crispy single or double crust, unless noted otherwise. I use expeller-pressed canola oil, which is more expensive, but worth it for health and taste, I believe. Its origins are a type of rapeseed, but bred to be low in erucic acid. Canola oil is the lowest in saturated fats at just 7 percent, but contains mostly monounsaturated fats, nearly as much as olive oil. It is high in ALA (alpha-linolenic acid) which is an omega 3 fat, with similar benefits of fish and fish oil, but NO fishy taste! I choose expeller-pressed oil because no solvents are used to release the oil, & it is less processed, so the result is more nutrients and antioxidants left intact. Most regular oils are processed by using potentially harmful chemical solvents to release the oil, such as hexane, after crushing and heating. Supposedly all solvent is removed, but one never knows.

Gluten-free crusts: I have experimented with several recipes, and found one that my gluten-free customers love. I mix several alternate flours, and then use both egg and butter to make them combine well. Along with the additional cost of the alternate flours and extra ingredients, there is a refrigeration process, and a partial baking step, so the crusts incur an upcharge of $3 per each, single crust (so a 2-crust pie is an addt'l $6). The crusts are flaky, with a hint of a shortbread flavor, and go equally well with fruit pie and quiche fillings. I also have several pies that automatically include almond flour or coconut crusts. Just ASK, and I'll be glad to discuss!

Fillings: For fruit fillings, I try to pick as much local, Ohio produce as possible, so I'm a frequent 'flyer' at central and north central Ohio orchards and patches. One just can't match the fresh-picked flavor of orchard apple varieties, and all of the local varieties of blueberries, strawberries and raspberries. I will typically freeze large quantities of berries during picking season, so I have them year-round. For apples, I seasonally pick bushels of several different pie apples, in September and October, so they are in limited quantity in the fall. For peaches, I've found that those shipped directly here from Georgia are the absolute best quality, in taste and texture, so I only purchase those for my pies. I use as little sweetener as possible to let that beautiful, fruit flavor shine through, and natural thickeners, such as flour, arrowroot, and tapioca flour.
For custard and nut pies, I make all from scratch, using fresh milk, coconut milk, or almond milk, eggs, pure vanilla extract, and generally, alternate thickeners such as arrowroot, and tapioca starch. Sometimes, I will add some cornstarch, as some pie custards need the setting properties of at least a little cornstarch. I do not add corn syrup (though some graham crackers used for crusts may contain a small amount), preferring either honey, real maple syrup, or a combination of the other natural sugar ingredients within each pie.